Funny Woman
Philippa Snow

In the summer of 1990, Jennifer Shrader Lawrence became the first girl to be born into her father Gary’s side of the family in a full half-century—a curious biographical detail that suggests both the fulfilment of an augury, and an innate predisposition for drama. That such a woman, clearly meant to be extraordinary, would grow up to become a major movie star is obvious. Obvious, too, is the way this masculine familial history went on to shape her celebrity persona: at the height of her fame, she positioned herself as a kind of every-tomboy, always tripping and swearing and generally behaving like what used to be described as a hoyden—so radiantly beautiful and blonde that to keep us from hating her for it, she had to pretend to be a frat boy, a dudebro, a slovenly wolf in the clothing of a Hollywood sheep. “I look at those interviews,” she says now, “and that person is annoying. I get why seeing that person everywhere would be annoying.” What we were seeing everywhere was a woman who was so indelibly a star that being asked to pretend she was a regular mess—even if we had previously been willing to believe she was a squirrel-skinning kid from the Ozarks, a con-man’s wife, the middle-aged inventor of the Miracle Mop, and so on—was a fantasy too far. One look at her has always been enough to affirm her irregular status: the skin like fondant, as if she were the subject of one of those strange viral videos where something is secretly a cake; the wide blue eyes atop the feline cheekbones; the hair just the right shade of Indiana sunshine; the tractor-beam charisma glowing underneath it all, drawing you in. A girl, the first in fifty years, made for fame and designed to be seen blown up on a screen, just as the prophecy foretold.
“This whole postpartum [reading] is just bullshit,” the genius director Lynn Ramsay told a journalist at Cannes this year, on the subject of her new film Die My Love. “It’s not about that.” In fact, Die My Love is a story about what might happen if a person with the aura and appearance of Jennifer Lawrence was dropped, as if from space, into the smoking and debris-strewn crater of a normal woman’s life. Lawrence’s character, Grace, is an author, although what she writes about remains a mystery. (Given that she keeps no books in the house, there is a non-zero chance she is secretly illiterate.) That her aspiration is to produce “the great American novel” is reflective of her evident, if vaguely defined, desire to be seen as special. When her husband, Jackson, is looking at the stars through a telescope, she refuses to join him, saying that the sight of them reminds her that she is “nothing.” It repulses her to know she is “part of something bigger,” when she feels like a vast, dazzling universe all by herself. The basic plot of Die My Love can be summed up in a sentence: Jackson and Grace have a baby, and Grace becomes creatively blocked, and then Jackson stops fucking her, and Grace goes insane. The pair have moved to a tumbledown house where Jackson’s uncle once lived, and in which he died under circumstances whose Freudian grotesquery is teased as a mystery, and then brushed off as a punchline. All of the horror emanates from Grace herself, from her head and her loins. Around her, other women tell her that her loneliness and mood swings are perfectly typical, a natural part of motherhood, midlife, and domesticity. “You know, everyone goes a little loopy the first year [after birth],” her mother-in-law insists. “I didn’t feel like myself for a while.” “Babies are hard,” a smiling young mother assures her at a party. “I don’t think anyone talks about that enough.” “It’s all anyone talks about,” Grace spits back, rolling her eyes. What she means is: nothing that is happening to the rest of you could possibly be the same thing that is happening to me.
Your house is falling apart, and neither of you wants to clean it; your husband doesn’t screw you enough, and perhaps he buys a stupid little dog; one of your in-laws dies, and another one drifts into senility. These are the kinds of indignities that pretty much everyone over thirty-five has to face for certain periods of time, brief or otherwise, and they are their own kind of horror movie—you grow up and the world tries to cover you with dirt, as if burying you alive. The fact that circumstances this ordinary should befall a woman as pretty and exciting as Grace feels somehow unbalanced, against nature, and this seeming inversion of the order of things can be seen as a catalyst for her breakdown. This is what Ramsay really means, I think, when she says that her film is not strictly about—or not only about—postpartum psychosis. It is also concerned with the feeling, especially striking for some women in midlife, that the hard work of adulthood can strip you of your sexual and professional magic. How destabilising, to find yourself no longer playing the ingenue-lead in the movie of your life! Grace is eventually committed to an unspecified institution for treatment, and there is an implication that she suffers from an also-unspecified mental health condition; later, she is given the requisite history of trauma for a complex female character in a horror-tinged contemporary film. The vagueness of her illness and the sudden deployment of her familial backstory, along with the absence of any identifying details about her interests, work, or personality, make Die My Love a less-than-satisfying character study. What works best is to imagine it instead as a tone poem—an abstracted depiction of feminine frustration and erotic obsolescence so texturally effective that the picture itself feels as if it has gone mad. What substance it offers is not narrative, but queasily, bluntly atmospheric. The film is as manic and grimy as its heroine—or, if you prefer, its antiheroine, though arguably one of its flaws is a failure of nerve when it comes to Grace’s badness, madness, and all-around dangerousness. She remains a loving mother, and is seemingly only unfaithful to her husband in her head.
In 2013, Lawrence won an Oscar for an earlier portrayal of a freaky babe: Tiffany, a volatile, sex-addicted widow, in Silver Linings Playbook. Whether a film in which a female character admitted to compulsively fucking all eleven people who worked in her office, “including the women,” would have been quite as warmly received if that woman had been aged in her late thirties—as she was in the original novel—as opposed to being played by the then-twenty-two-year-old Lawrence is unclear. The part is underwritten, just as the role of Grace would be a decade-plus later: the mentally-ill sexpot archetype, such as it is, rarely offers much of substance for an actress, relying as it does on the tension between her immaculate movie star’s face, and the titillating, filthy things that the character she’s playing has supposedly done with her body. What made Tiffany compelling was Lawrence’s inherent watchability, the charm she brought even to the character’s most inglorious moments. Walking to the stage to collect her statuette for Best Actress, in a voluminous Dior gown that made her look like a bride, she tripped and fell on the stairs. A photograph of her holding her face in one hand with embarrassment quickly went viral, looking as it did like a tongue-in-cheek fashion campaign; it so neatly summarised how she was perceived in the media, as a great, crashing beauty with a tendency to crash headfirst into the furniture, that it became instantly iconic. “I was so dykey,” she had told an interviewer at Rolling Stone in 2011, tasked with describing herself as a child. Unfortunate language aside, this particular myth—the myth of Lawrence the boy in a hot girl’s body, the feminine changeling who stole into her father’s all-male lineage by surprise—was for many years a cornerstone of her promotional profiles and appearances, perhaps because the idea itself was irresistible: so easily marketable as to seem like the invention of a boardroom full of men, even if it was in fact almost totally authentic. An incomplete list of the things which contributed to Lawrence’s ladette reputation in the early-to-mid-2010s: that fall, of course; a story about getting Cheeto dust on her costumes while filming American Hustle; her flirtatious on-camera banter with one Jack Nicholson; her tendency to talk about burgers and pizza, and to loudly proclaim just how hungry she was on the red carpet; her joke about carrying “copious numbers of butt plugs” in her suitcase on Conan O’Brien.
Lawrence did not choose to be born female, or to grow up into someone who looked like a marketing executive’s dream. All she could choose was how best to demonstrate her essential humanity, even as certain forces would eventually work to dehumanise her. In 2014, hackers stole intimate photographs from numerous celebrities, in what would come to be called, quite gruesomely, “The Fappening.” One of these celebrities was Lawrence, and if she had previously positioned herself as a frat boy, a dudebro, and so on, this incident served as a reminder that she was still a woman, apt to be subjected to the same humiliations as the rest of her kind. “It is not a scandal. It is a sex crime,” she told Vanity Fair, entirely correctly. “It is a sexual violation. It’s disgusting… Just because I’m a public figure, just because I’m an actress, does not mean that I asked for this. It does not mean that it comes with the territory. It’s my body, and it should be my choice, and the fact that it is not my choice is absolutely disgusting.” What became obvious was that her positioning of herself as a boyish doofus, even if it had partly been a result of her background and personal history, had also been a way of creating a certain level of distance between Jennifer Lawrence the person, and Jennifer Lawrence the pin-up. “It was a defense mechanism,” she told the New Yorker in 2025, “to just be, like, ‘I’m not like that! I poop my pants every day!’” The word “that,” in this context, was shorthand for the Otherness of stardom, the glamour and poise that was expected of a woman in Hollywood. She was, in a sense, the inverse of Grace in Die My Love: an extraordinary woman who believed that she was totally average, in spite of her circumstances. What she wanted, more than anything, was for us to look through the figurative telescope of her fame, and to see her as “nothing”—as “part of something bigger” in the same imperfect way that the rest of us were, as opposed to being an entire constellation in one shining girl.
Yet another way in which she was the inverse of Grace: she had tried to avoid being sexualised, and yet still found herself being objectified and used against her will. As a counter-measure, she attempted to take back her own erotic narrative with the 2018 film Red Sparrow, the tale of a Bolshoi ballerina named Dominika who retrains as a spy after breaking her leg. More specifically, she retrains as a “sparrow,” a honey-trapper trained in sexual seduction, at an institution she refers to as “whore school.” Initially, Lawrence had turned down the script because she felt that the content was far too explicit—post-hack, she saw it as an opportunity to be publicly naked by choice, and not by force. Red Sparrow is not a good film, and the cartoonish Russian accent that Lawrence adopts in it is not good, either. What is interesting about it is its place in her history, metatextually speaking: being manipulated and exposed as a young actress, after all, must also sometimes feel like being sent to “whore school.” Early on in Lawrence’s career, she revealed at the Elle Woman awards in 2017, “a female producer had me do a nude line-up with about five women who were much, much thinner than me. And we all stood side by side with only paste-ons covering our privates. After that degrading and humiliating line-up, the female producer told me I should use the naked photos of myself as inspiration for my diet.” Everything about this image—the firing-squad nature of the line-up, the forced semi-nudity, and even the implicit and illicit grubbiness of documenting it all with a Polaroid camera—suggests something which itself belongs in Red Sparrow, a sadistic, psychologically destructive test designed to make the woman undergoing it into someone other than herself. When she complained to another, male producer, Lawrence added, he told her that he could not fathom why “everyone” believed she was “so fat,” since he thought she was “perfectly fuckable.” Such gallantry is typical of the movie industry, where actresses who do not enjoy explicit compliments are treated like scolds. Like undercover spies, they are asked to hide the truth, to fix their faces, and to smile at their own subjugation.
Lawrence’s decision to make Red Sparrow reflected a common misconception: that a woman being sexual but also violent was inherently more feminist than a woman being sexual and sweet. Her character was not a pretty, supplicating Bond girl, but a powerful aggressor. She was also, unfortunately, not much of a character at all, which somewhat undermined the exercise vis-à-vis her actress’ sexual liberation. “Dominika, beautiful yet often blank,” Anthony Lane wrote in his review for the New Yorker, “remains a cipher without quite deepening into an enigma.” The irony here is that almost no famous woman is less of an enigma or a cipher than Jennifer Lawrence. Her promotional tour for Die My Love has thus far been more interesting than the film itself. Where Grace, aside from her madness and her motherhood, lacks a distinct personality, Lawrence’s spills over with abandon in interviews, just as it always has—the difference is that certain facets of her character have altered, if subtly, with age and experience. Gone are the boasts about her dietary excess; gone are the mentions of bourbon and beer; gone are the slyly self-deprecating comments which sought to convince us, her audience, that she was nothing special. At thirty-six, as a mother to two children, she is both more radiant and less apologetic for her radiance than ever; her wit has been sharpened by age and experience into an acuminated weapon, wielded with great confidence. (When a clip of her facetiously telling Leonardo DiCaprio, a serial dater of very young women, that he would “look good with a teenage daughter” went viral, the joke this time was not that Lawrence had misspoken without thinking, as it might have been in 2015, but that she had chosen exactly the right words to land a plausibly deniable blow.) Just as it had been an error to assume that Red Sparrow’s alembic of nudity and violence would be enough to make it a feminist statement, her greatest mistake when deciding on a persona was to think that being funny and being normal were synonymous—to confuse her natural gift for comedy for relatability, when really, her blend of traditionally Hollywood looks and elastic comic chops makes her as singular as is humanly possible, to the degree that any beautiful, talented, millionaire icon is “humanly” anything.
More than any role that she has played before, Lawrence’s turn as Grace seems intended to earn the respect of the industry. Per a flurry of press, it is her movie, a showcase for an actress who is giving it her all. Lynn Ramsay’s cinema is one that runs on vibes, so the work lives or dies by the casting of its lead. In Morvern Callar, Samantha Morton’s finely-tuned performance is almost exclusively interior, and she has the added advantage of looking like a ‘real’ person, meaning an un-famous civilian; ditto Joaquin Phoenix in You Were Never Really Here, who speaks fewer than a hundred words in the film, but burns through the screen like a cigarette through silk. In Die My Love, Lawrence’s evident, galactic starriness—which does, on the one hand, bolster our impression of Grace’s sexual neglect as a genuine catastrophe, à la the casting of Elizabeth Taylor in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof—risks making Grace’s breakdown too hip, too telegenic. Many of her wildest gestures have the air of an edgy editorial about them: a touch of the Manic-Depressive Pixie Dream Girl. She spits beer like a fountain; she strips down to her underwear and jumps in the pool; she crawls sexily around on all fours, and on several occasions, she dances with frenzied and flailing abandon. Twice, she drops into a yogic uttanasana, dropping forward at the waist in a motion that suggests nothing so much as an actress in rehearsals limbering up for a take. When she appears nude, it is in painterly light, the mood more sensuous than raw. Her beauty, in short, exudes as much of a dangerous, nuclear glow as her madness. Certain critics have compared her performance in the film to that of Gena Rowlands in A Woman Under the Influence, but Lawrence does not yet have the fortysomething Rowlands’ faded grandeur, her monumental blend of sensitivity and strength. She is a wonderfully gifted comedienne, and a naturally amusing and charming celebrity, and for good or for ill, just a little of this innate silliness bleeds over into Grace, making what might have been frightening seem, at times, a touch too kooky to be visceral.
Like many famous actors, Lawrence wears her public profile like a second skin onscreen. She is a woman, one might say, under the influence of herself. What she has is a presence entirely her own, and a perfect, genuinely liberating demonstration of her one-off aura occurs in a scene from the 2023 sex comedy, No Hard Feelings. In that film, Lawrence’s character is skinny-dipping when a trio of teens steal her clothes from the beach; fully nude, she emerges from the water and engages in a fist-fight with them in the sand. A slapstick gag in this vein would more typically fall to a Jason Segel or a Will Ferrell, and yet here was one of the most desirable women in the world beating the shit out of three other people with her clothes off, and even if her hotness was part of the joke, it was not the whole punchline. I thought about the naked fight scene as I watched Grace crawling on the floor over and over again in Die My Love, and I realized that somehow, this one dumb snippet of a fun, dumb movie successfully housed the most out-there thrill I had seen Jennifer Lawrence deliver to date. More transgressive than a woman being naked and violent, or being naked and unhinged, is a woman being naked and violent and unhinged, and also doing it in a way that is sexless and totally hilarious—a sight so rare than it is difficult to think offhand of another example in cinema. Here, Lawrence shifted the paradigm, and if we made more films where women could be darkly, grossly funny in this vein, we would have more perfect vehicles for her talent. No more onscreen breakdowns, or high-end Oscar bait; no more proclamations of what David Foster Wallace might refer to as her regular-guyness. To have what the media considers to be the perfect female body, and to be so funny you can still make the sight of it purely, undeniably comic, in defiance of all patriarchal convention, is a truly extraordinary feat, and it takes the kind of long-prophesied girl you have to wait a half century for.
Click here purchase the issue in which this piece originally appeared, or subscribe to receive all future issues as soon as they're published.
You can subscribe to our infrequent newsletter here: